home up a  level contact us site search site map

A REGISTER OF COMPLETED AND ONGOING RESEARCH BY HEALTH ADVISERS

 

Topics

Stigma and Sexually Transmitted Infections: Are attitudes towards people with sexually transmitted infections as punitive
as they are perceived to be?

"That's the whole thing-to get rid of it": Stigma, Sexually Transmitted Infections and Attendance at the GUM Clinic

Developmental Psychology; comparison of the risk perceptions between genders in late adolescence

Provider Referrals: Experience and Attitudes of Sexual Contacts

Assessing the impact of pre-test counselling upon HIV transmission, knowledge and motivation to change risk behaviour.

Some Peoples’ Psychological Experiences of Attending a Sexual Health Clinic and Having an STI

Clinical Supervision is Beneficial to Health Advisers/Clinical Nurse Specialists Working within Genito-urinary Medicine

Working Together: meeting the needs of the Black African clients in a UK HIV clinical service

A Literature Review and Research Proposal to Explore the Attitudes and Opinions of Teenagers to Safer Sex

A literature review to explore the knowledge and attitudes of health care workers to HIV and AIDS

How do we do what we do with patients and how can we do it better?

Date: 11th Feb 2003

Name: Ellen Mulholland

Address:

Gum Dept., University Hospital of Hartlepool, Holdforth Rd. Hartlepool.TS24 9AH

Telephone: 01429 522577

Post: Health Adviser

Title of research: Stigma and Sexually Transmitted Infections: Are attitudes towards people with sexually transmitted infections as punitive
as they are perceived to be?

If the research work is complete, when was it completed? January 2003

Summary of research topic

Previous research has identified perceptions of social stigma as a main barrier to attendance for sexual health screening. Although published research surrounding the psychology of social stigma in relation to common sexually transmitted infections is lacking, a wide body of evidence has accumulated suggesting that only a minority of people hold highly negative views of people suffering from HIV, within which gender differences have been found (eg Yong & Miller 1993). This is in direct contrast with the felt stigma of those infected (Green 1995). As negative attitudes among the general public towards stigmatised people are important sources of enacted stigma, the current study employed a simple survey design to investigate participants own attitudes towards people with STIs in comparison to their perceptions of others attitudes and to identify any attitudinal differences between genders. 30 (15 male/15 female) members of
the general public were invited to complete a two-part likert style attitude questionnaire, adapted to investigate attitudes towards people who have STIs. A series of t-tests were performed and the results indicate that 1) a significant difference exists between participants own positive and negative attitudes (t = 8.706; df = 29; p = .000; < 0.05) indicating an overall liberal attitude towards people suffering from STIs 2) a significant difference exists between participants perceptions of the general public's attitude and their own, with the general public's attitude perceived as generally more negative (t = 3.238; df 29; p = .0015; < 0.05). 3) No significant differences were found between males and females.
Main conclusion:
As the participants essentially form part of the general public, and social stigma is proposed to be a manifestation of social standards
(Goffman 1963), these findings appear counterintuitive. This raises questions regarding why the general public perceive others to hold
negative attitudes towards STI sufferers when they themselves don't, and how has such a viewpoint become stereotypical. Further research is required to investigate this phenomenon.


Date: 14.10.02

Name: Ellen Mulholland

Address:

Gum Dept., Hartlepool General Hospital, Holdforth Rd. Hartlepool.

Telephone: 01429 522577

Post: Clinical Nurse Specialist/Health Adviser

Title of research: "That's the whole thing-to get rid of it": Stigma, Sexually Transmitted Infections and Attendance at the GUM Clinic

If the research work is complete, when was it completed? May 2002

Summary of research topic

Abstract

Previous research has identified many barriers that inhibit the uptake of sexual health screening which include fears of embarrassment, perceptions of stigma and perceived invulnerability as a function of stereotypical beliefs surrounding the risks of contracting sexually transmitted infections STI's (Holgate & Longman 1998, Meyer -Weitz et al 2000). However little is known about the health seeking behaviours of those at risk as psychological research in this area is lacking. Employing a theoretical sampling technique, this qualitative study utilised a phenomenological interpretative approach to interview ten patients (5 female/5 male) with an age range of 18-28 years (mean age: 22 years) attending a Genito-Urinary Medicine clinic. The aim being to explore their perceptions of sexual health screening, to ascertain whether these perceptions are endorsed by the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) (Ajzen 1985, 1991), and to identify any gender differences. Burnard's (1991) stage method of thematic analysis identified seven salient themes which were all dominated by perceptions of stigma; 1) stigma surrounding STI's, 2) fear of exposure, 3) isolation, 4) reluctance to attend, 5) contamination, 6) relationship issues and 7) perceived invulnerability. The findings suggest that perceptions of contamination seemed to underlie motivation to attend despite the perceived barriers. Significant gender differences were also identified. The TPB cannot account for these findings.

Main conclusion

In support of previous research this study has demonstrated that sexual health screening does take place against a prevailing sexual (patriarchal) ideology that plays a major role in the social construction of barriers to sexual health care especially for women. Although the medical profession and the government are recommending destigmatisation of STI's and GUM clinics (Foley & Patel 2001, DOH 2001) which ironically they have played a role in creating, it is possible that this stigma is motivating individuals to attend. The participants of this study all voiced a real reluctance to attend the GUM clinic and described the psychological discomfort that they experienced as a result of stereotypical notions surrounding STI's and the GUM clinic. However, although destigmatisation of GUM clinics would be a positive action to lessen this discomfort which might make it easier for individuals to attend, it could be argued that the active voices of the participants in this study demonstrated that the desire to "get rid" of the perceived contamination associated with the stigma of STI's, may have paradoxically facilitated their attendance over and above the personal and organisational obstacles. Should STI's therefore be destigmatised ? Further psychological research is essential in order to address this question as there are huge implications for health promotion/massmedia campaigns, governmental policies, aswell as professional practice.

Date: 26.3.01

Name: Ellen Mulholland

Address:

Gum Dept.,

Hartlepool General Hospital,

Holdforth Rd.

Hartlepool.

Telephone: 01429 522577

 Post: Clinical Nurse Specialist/Health Adviser

 Title of research: Developmental Psychology; comparison of the risk perceptions between genders in late adolescence

If the research work is complete, when was it completed? November 2000

Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions:

The transitional period of adolescence from childhood to adulthood has been characterised as a relatively high-risk stage of life which makes them vulnerable to the adverse biopsychosocial consequences of risk. However, adolescent experimentation has been viewed as psychologically adaptive, as experimentation facilitates social and psychological development, autonomy, self-regulation and independence. As a result of these complex developmental processes, adolescent risk taking is multifactoral involving such factors as social conformity and peer influence, together with personality factors including extraversion/introversion and high sensation seeking traits. Furthermore, risk taking has also been linked with the concept of "optimistic bias" whereby individuals hold a sense of invulnerability as they unrealistically assess their own risks as less than the risks of others. Risk appraisals have also been found to be modified by prior experience. Knowledge of these factors is of particular importance for practice for both clinic based one to one and broader community based behavioural interventions. A wide body of evidence exists that supports the theory that adolescent's perception of risk predicts subsequent behaviour. More specifically, perceptions of the beneficial consequences of risky activities have been found to be a significant predictor of intentions to participate in them. Significant gender differences in risk perceptions have also been consistently found. In order to build upon previous research and to gain further understanding into the risk perceptions of adolescents, the current study utilised an independent groups design to investigate the relationship between the perceived positive consequences (the benefits), perceived negative consequences (the costs), and intentions to participate in a variety of risky activities. This was combined with an investigation into the gender differences between risk perceptions. Utilising a purposive quota sampling technique, 56 adolescents (25-male/31 female) with a mean age of 16.8 years (age range 16-18 years) were selected from a College of Further Education in the North East of England. They were instructed to complete the three part Cognitive Appraisal of Risky Events Questionnaire which reflects six common risk factors; illicit drug use, aggressive and illegal behaviours, risky sexual activities, heavy drinking and academic behaviours. Independent samples t-tests revealed statistically significant gender differences between perceptions of negative consequences of the risky activities (t=2.938; df 54; p= .005; < 0.05) and between perceptions of positive consequences of risky activities (t= 2.056; df 54; p=  .045; < 0.05) with females perceiving less negative consequences than males. A Pearson's correlation also revealed a strong positive relationship between perceived positive consequences and intentions to participate in the risky activities (r= 0.836; df 54; p= 0.01; < 0.05). The findings are discussed together with methodological limitations and implications for future research.

Date: 5.11.00

Name: Chris Faldon

Address: Department of GU Medicine

               Newcastle General Hospital

               Westgate Road

               Newcastle NE4 6BE

Telephone: 0191 219 5011

 Post: Health Adviser

 Title of research: "Come & see me. You may have a sexual infection."  (Provider Referrals: Experience and Attitudes of Sexual Contacts)

If the research work is complete, when was it completed? October 2000

Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions:

Chlamydia trachomatis is a significant threat to the sexual health of a large proportion of the sexually active UK population. Asymptomatic cases of infection are frequently detected through partner notification. It has been a key component of controlling sexually transmitted infections.

Few studies have attempted to examine the acceptability of partner notification to patients, partners and health care workers. Health Advisers working in Genito-Urinary Medicine (GUM) clinics take the lead responsibility in tracing sexual contacts.

A qualitative study was performed to address the following areas:

1.      Examine the impact on an individual of being informed by a health professional of a specific sexual infection risk.

2.      Search out any changes to their feelings and reactions to this life experience over a period of time.

3.    Identify factors that may influence coping strategies and thus inform professional practice.

‘In-depth’ interviews were selected as the method of choice. Recruitment proved to be extremely difficult. Five men agreed to be interviewed by the lead researcher and only one went on to a second interview 3 months later. Sufficient data however was collected to address the study aims.

Three key issues emerged from the data;

bullet

Vulnerability: The human reactions to the threat of receiving bad news.

bullet

Searching: The response to seek out support and other coping strategies.

bullet

Power: Concerned with control issues and the dynamics of relationships

The men were broadly supportive of the intervention of partner notification and articulated views on how it had impacted on their lives.

A range of professional implications, recommendations for further work and research was proposed.

Date: 4.11.99

 Name: Paul Nicholls and Mime Mathews

 Address: James Paget Health Care Trust, Lowestoft Road, Gomeston, Norfolk

 Telephone: 01493 452747  

Post: Health Adviser

 Title of research: Assessing the impact of pre-test counselling upon HIV transmission, knowledge and motivation to change risk behaviour.

 If the research work is complete, when was it completed? July 1999 

 If the research has been published, please give details: The research was presented as a poster at the AIDS Impact Conference in Ottawa, Canada, July 1999.

Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions: Pre-test counselling provides a unique opportunity for health education and planned behaviour change. The research hypothesis is that knowledge about HIV is increased by pre-test counselling (following DOH guidelines 1996) but motivation to change risk behaviour is not significantly changed.

Preliminary results showed initially variable knowledge about HIV, with low knowledge scores amongst some clients. Some improvement in knowledge was achieved in most cases by second testing. Confidence in efficacy was high however in the majority of respondents. Pre-test counselling did not significantly alter the profile of motivation for change scores.

 Date: 14.10.00

 Name: Helen Holgate

 Address: c/o SHASTD Research Officer

Telephone:

 Post: Ex-Senior Health Adviser, Kingston Hospital

 Title of research: Some Peoples’ Psychological Experiences of Attending a Sexual Health Clinic and Having an STI

 If the research work is complete, when was it completed? 1996

If the research has been published, please give details: Published in SHASTD newsletter Spring 1999 and the Journal of the Royal Society, Vol 118, No.2 April 1998

Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions: This study considers aspects of the experiences of a group of people attending a sexual health clinic and receiving the diagnosis of a sexually transmitted infection (STI). The study was conducted in the form of action research using a qualitative approach. Participants consisted of eight attenders at a sexual health clinic who had been diagnosed with a sexually transmitted infection. Counselling skills and techniques were used throughout semi-structured interviews to explore participants’ feelings about these issues. Thematic analysis was used to generate themes of importance to the participants.

 Some people who had been to a sexual health clinic and received a diagnosis of a sexually transmitted infection were found to experience feelings of anxiety, stigma and isolation.

Date: 20.10.99

 Name: Susan A. Padmore

 Address: c/o SHASTD Research Officer

Telephone:

 Post: Health Adviser

 Title of research: Clinical Supervision is Beneficial to Health Advisers/Clinical Nurse Specialists Working within Genito-urinary Medicine 

If the research work is complete, when was it completed? June 1997

 If the research has been published, please give details:

 Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions: The author’s hypothesis was that clinical supervision is beneficial to health advisers/clinical nurse specialists working within Genito-Urinary Medicine. Interviews with Health Advisers and Clinical Nurse Specialists supported this hypothesis.

 Date: 27.03.00

Name: Sandra Smith

 Address: Royal Glamorgan Hospital

                Ynysmaerdy

                Llantrisant

                South Wales CF72 8XR

 Telephone: 01443 443597

 Post: Health Adviser

Title of research: A literature review to explore the knowledge and attitudes of health care workers to HIV and AIDS

 If the research work is complete, when was it completed? April 1999

If the research has been published, please give details: Submitted as part fulfilment of the M.Sc. in Sexual Health and Reproductive Studies.

 Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions: The dissertation describes a review of the literature on the impact of knowledge and attitudes of health care professionals in relation to HIV and AIDS and the barriers affecting the quality of caring for people with the disease. People with AIDS (PWA) not only have to face the biophysical consequences of a terminal disease, but also the social impact or stigma, associated with this illness. This paper found that health care professionals’ knowledge is increasing over time, as they become more familiar with treating people with AIDS. However, there remain gaps in education and training, which clearly need to be addressed, as HIV and AIDS remain the epidemic of our time. The dissertation concludes with implications for practice.

Date: 20.03.00

 Name: Rose Tobin

 Address: c/o SHASTD Research Officer

Telephone:

 Post: Senior Health Adviser

 Title of research: Working Together: meeting the needs of the Black African clients in a UK HIV clinical service

 If the research work is complete, when was it completed? April 1999

 If the research has been published, please give details:

Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions:

Evaluation of  how a voluntary community based project, Africare, which offers advocacy and an outreach service to black African people affected by HIV/AIDS in the community, is incorporated into a local clinic based service.

Date: 30.03.00

 Name: Jean Beard

 Address: GUM Clinic

                Royal Glamorgan Hospital

                Ynysmaerdy

                 Llantrisant

                 South Wales CF72 8XR

 Telephone: 01443 443597

Post: Health Adviser

 Title of research: A Literature Review and Research Proposal to Explore the Attitudes and Opinions of Teenagers to Safer Sex

 If the research work is complete, when was it completed? May 1999

 If the research has been published, please give details: The dissertation was submitted as part of the requirements for the M.Sc. in Reproductive and Sexual Health Studies. It was presented to the annual Welsh MSSVD Conference and to the Welsh Office Development and Research Bureau.

Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions: The aim of the literature review is to analyse the information currently available about the attitudes and opinions of adolescents to safe sexual practices. It is evident that there has been little research into teenagers’ opinions about safe sex. For this reason it was decided to design a qualitative research study. The research proposed will use a grounded theory approach to explore the opinions of teenagers who volunteer to share their views on safe sex, in relation to their own sexual behaviour and sexual health.

Date: 2000

Name: James Monteith, Jo Greenaway, David Owen.

Address: Central Middlesex Hospital, Acton Lane, London, NW10 7NS

Contact: 0208 453 2220  or e-mail joanne.greenaway@cmh-tr.nthames.nhs.uk

Post: Health Advisers

Title of research: How do we do what we do with patients and how can we do it better?

Summary of research topic or problem and any findings or conclusions:

"Is Health Advising just a job or does it have the characteristics of a profession? Are Health Advisers merely ancillary workers for the medical profession carrying out a delegated range of tasks, or do they have a coherent way of conceptualising their role in a way that relates theory to practice, and which betokens a distinct professional identity and role"?

 The overall aim of the Research is to evaluate and conceptualise Health Adviser interactions with a specific patient group: HIV antibody positive gay men referred for psychological support; with a view towards developing and supporting an evidence based Health Adviser practice applicable to all patients referred. It is a baseline study.

 From the responses to the patient questionnaire the authors considered three specific though inter-related questions:

i) What knowledge, skills and attitudes inform a Health Adviser interaction with a patient in a HIV/GUM centre?

ii) How can we better define and characterise our patient interactions?

iii) What implication do these findings have for the professional development of Health Advising with particular reference to the core areas of Health Advising (SHASTD – Guidelines for Good Practice, 1999)

 The argument of this study is that Health Advising is not just a job comprised of a range of specific delegated tasks. The authors have identified our professional core skill we counsel patients in sexual infections; and we believe as Health Advisers, we are beginning to conceptualise our counselling practice appropriately. When committed and experienced Health Advisers meet and we discuss our work; we instinctively recognise each other as fellow professionals; though we may have come from many different backgrounds and theoretical trainings.

Full poster presented at SHASTD conference 2000

  last updated 11-02-03

home up a  level contact us site search site map

           postal address: SHASTD, MSF Centre, 33-37 Moreland Street, London, EC1V 8HA.                      

  electronic mail

Copyright of text and images contained on this site is held by SHASTD, unless otherwise indicated. We request you do not use material without prior consent. The user assumes the entire risk as to the accuracy and use of the information. This includes advice given by email. Full disclaimer